- Charles Smith Cabernet 2011 Washington State Light body, low tanins 87 pts
- Bob -liked this - had New Year's Eve. - would buy this one again
- Thank you Charles, very enjoyable. Needed to breath and was very good.
- What a unbelievable merlot. Very smooth. Something to drink now and also cellar for a few years
- Charles Ellner, Epernay Brut Reserve 40% Pinot